When Three Worlds Collide: A Review of Abdulrazak Gurnah’s Theft – Olukorede S. Yishau

Africa’s most recent Nobel laureate in Literature, Abdulrazak Gurnah, returns with another powerful work, Theft. True to his literary reputation, Gurnah once again probes the intersections of memory, belonging, and displacement in a rapidly changing world. The novel follows three principal characters—Karim, Fauzia, and Badar—and the intricate ways in which their lives intertwine amid social transformations and moral uncertainties. The story is told from the point of views of the trio.

At the beginning, each character inhabits a world defined by difference and isolation. Karim’s world is shaped by emotional estrangement. His mother leaves her marriage and returns to her father’s home, and from that moment, mother and son exchange few words. Even after she remarries, the warmth between them remains tentative, though her new husband shows Karim the affection she once withheld. Karim’s formative years, therefore, are marked by quiet resentment and the psychological residue of parental separation—a common theme in societies negotiating between tradition and individual agency.

Fauzia’s world is gentler, yet shadowed by fragility. Her mother’s love is all-encompassing, protective to the point of suffocation. Her father, a man of few words, expresses his affection in acts rather than speech. Fauzia also lives with the “falling sickness,” epilepsy, a condition that sets her apart and attracts both sympathy and superstition. Her best friend, Hawa, circles her with the constancy of a guardian spirit. Through Fauzia, Gurnah captures the intimate anxieties of African domestic life, where illness is both a personal struggle and a communal concern framed by cultural beliefs.

Badar, on the other hand, occupies a world of servitude and marginality. His is the life of a boy born into disadvantage, struggling against economic deprivation and the hierarchies that quietly sustain inequality. He is a symbol of the countless young men who drift along the edges of postcolonial societies—hardworking, unseen, and uncertain of tomorrow.

Karim’s return to Zanzibar after completing his university education in Dar es Salaam marks the point where these distinct worlds begin to converge. The city he comes back to is not the one he left. Zanzibar, with its layered history of slavery, trade, and colonialism, is now being remade by new forces. Tourism is reshaping its streets and its values, and technology is bridging old boundaries while deepening class divides. In this shifting landscape, Karim and Fauzia meet and fall in love. Their romance, at first a private rebellion against loneliness, soon becomes a social affair. In traditional Tanzanian culture, relationships are rarely hidden for long. Community observation and family involvement turn private desire into public expectation, and soon, talk of marriage follows.

When Badar’s world merges with theirs, Gurnah constructs a layered social tableau. The convergence of these three lives symbolises more than personal connection. It mirrors the broader collision between the old and the new, the local and the global, the privileged and the dispossessed. Each character embodies a fragment of a society negotiating modernity: Karim, the educated cosmopolitan struggling with inherited wounds; Fauzia, the vulnerable yet resilient woman navigating the constraints of gender and tradition; and Badar, the overlooked youth whose struggles reflect systemic inequities.

Through their entangled stories, Theft becomes more than a tale of love or parental betrayal. It is a sociological portrait of Zanzibar and, by extension, Africa’s coastal societies, where the residues of colonialism still shape personal destinies. The novel situates individual choices within the larger machinery of economic transformation, cultural expectation, and historical memory.

Gurnah’s prose is measured and introspective. He writes with the compassion of one who understands exile not merely as physical dislocation but as an emotional and moral condition. His characters are perpetually searching—for affection, for meaning, for a place in a world that is both familiar and alien. In Theft, the act of stealing is not always about possessions; it can be the theft of innocence, of opportunity, or of one’s sense of self.

As European tourists flood Zanzibar’s beaches and global modernity knocks on the doors of traditional households, Gurnah invites readers to consider what is lost and what is gained when cultures collide. The meeting of Karim, Fauzia, and Badar’s worlds thus reflects a larger human story—the story of adaptation, survival, and the quest for dignity in an unequal world.
In this novel, which reaffirms Gurnah’s place among the great chroniclers of postcolonial life, prose and dialogue flow seamlessly into one another, without the boundary of quotation marks. The reader must discern where speech begins and ends, and where narration quietly resumes. His strength lies not in spectacle but in subtlety, in his ability to expose how personal lives are shaped by invisible historical forces. In the quiet unfolding of these three lives, we see the restless spirit of a continent in transition and the universal longing for belonging in a world that keeps changing its face. The stylistic risks he takes in this work may test the patience of ‘lazy’ readers.
Gurnah unveils pivotal moments with the quiet subtlety of one who seems to let them slip by accident, a strategy that keeps us turning the pages for a better grasp of what is going on.

The ending of Theft unfolds with quiet intensity, gathering the many threads of the story into a resolution that feels both surprising and inevitable. Gurnah achieves this without theatrics; instead, he allows meaning to emerge through silence, gesture, and emotional restraint. The novel’s power lies in its shifting perspectives, drawing readers deep into one character’s consciousness before reorienting them through another’s. In doing so, Gurnah exposes the limits of understanding and the distortions of memory that shape human relationships.

As the story moves towards its close, the past hovers like an inescapable presence, pressing upon the lives of those who wish to break free from it. Yet, amid the shadows, there are glimmers of renewal. Gurnah captures this delicate balance between loss and hope, reminding us that even in a world scarred by displacement and misunderstanding, the possibility of healing endures. The final pages leave the reader suspended between sorrow and redemption, unsure which will triumph, but deeply moved by the honesty of the struggle.
***Olukorede S. Yishau is the author of two novels: In The Name of Our Father and After The End; a collection of short stories: Vaults of Secrets; and a travel book: United Countries of America and Other Travel Tales. He is concluding work on his third novel. He lives in Houston, Texas. 
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Stay up-to-date
[madmimi id=3246405]